Aikido comparison often reduces to style and ceremony, but the split between orthodox Aikido and Icho-ryu is practical and personal. Bernie Lau built Icho-ryu from his Aikido roots to keep Aiki principles while adding strikes, tested throws, jujutsu methods and police tactics for real resistance.
Aikido comparison: core differences between Icho-ryu and orthodox Aikido
Orthodox Aikido traces to Morihei Ueshiba and a curriculum that favors circular movement, blending and cooperative kata practice. Training tends to avoid hard striking and full force sparring, and it places a strong weight on spiritual practice and nonviolence.
Icho-ryu preserves Aiki ideas such as timing, blending and joint control yet changes how those ideas are applied. Where orthodox Aikido relies on cooperative practice, Icho-ryu adds atemi and pressure testing so techniques work against resisting opponents. The result is a system built with arrest and control use in mind rather than demonstration or spiritual training alone.
Origins that shaped practical choices
Bernie Lau and the reason for change
Bernie Lau began Aikido in 1955 under Koichi Tohei and received early promotions signed by Morihei Ueshiba. While teaching and working as a Seattle police detective he found some dojo methods failed under real resistance. Lau resigned from the Aikikai in 1975 and used a private dojo, the Washington Budokan, to blend Aikido with other arts and police combatives. By about 1980 he formalized the curriculum now known as Icho-ryu.
Lineage and influences that matter for practice
Icho-ryu draws on multiple sources documented in Lau’s work:
- Daito ryu Aiki jujutsu as the classical Aiki root
- Goju ryu Karate for atemi and close range strikes
- Kodokan Judo for throws and randori style pressure testing
- Danzan ryu and Wally Jay techniques for compact joint locks
- Taiho jutsu for arrest, cuffing and baton use
Those influences explain why Icho-ryu looks familiar to an Aikido practitioner yet functions differently when a partner resists.
Technical contrasts: what you will see on the mat
Strikes and set up tactics
Icho-ryu uses atemi to create openings. Strikes are delivered as set ups to force reactions that make locks and throws effective. Orthodox Aikido teaches atemi historically, but many schools do not integrate strikes as a routine training tool for live resistance.
Locks, throws and ground work
- Locks: Icho-ryu often applies small circle jujitsu detail to increase pain compliance and control during an arrest. That comes from Wally Jay style influence.
- Throws: Icho-ryu adopts judo methods and tests throws in more forceful scenarios. Orthodox Aikido throws remain central but are most often taught with cooperative partners.
- Ground work: Icho-ryu trains transitional newaza to regain standing quickly and to control a suspect until cuffs are applied. Extended ground grappling is not a primary focus.
Randori and pressure training
Icho-ryu includes randori influenced drills that expose techniques to uncooperative partners and multiple attacker scenarios. Traditional Aikido does use randori in some schools but often without the same level of full force testing used in Icho-ryu.
Weapons and police tools
Icho-ryu incorporates weapon defenses and weapon retention drills drawn from Taiho jutsu and classical aiki methods. Training uses wooden or rubber training gear and scenario practice for baton and knife defense tailored to law enforcement tasks. Orthodox Aikido contains many weapons forms historically but tends to focus on kata style and safe partner work.
Training structure and classroom rules
- Warm up and ukemi remain core in both systems so practitioners learn safe falling.
- Icho-ryu progress moves from kata practice to active, scenario oriented drills that include controlled strikes, pressure testing and role play. Safety rules require controlled contact, tap signals and graduated intensity.
- Rankings are awarded internally in Icho-ryu much like in Aikido, but there is no global federation for Icho-ryu and no sport circuit.
Ethics and use of force
Both arts share a restraint ethic inherited from Aiki traditions. Icho-ryu frames that ethic around policing realities: the aim is control with minimal lasting injury and a clear path to handcuff a subject. Lau taught that techniques must protect officers and suspects, and that measured force is standard practice. Orthodox Aikido stresses nonviolence and harmony as philosophical foundations and often frames technique within a broader moral practice.
Practical differences summed up
- Icho-ryu vs Aikido in real encounters: Icho-ryu is adapted for resisting opponents with added strikes, tested throws and police procedures. Orthodox Aikido remains focused on blending and cooperative training with a strong spiritual thread.
- Icho-ryu practical vs traditional Aikido: Icho-ryu trades some dojo formality for scenario realism and a syllabus that deals with weapon defense and arrest techniques.
- For law enforcement use: Icho-ryu adaptations for real world policing include come along holds, baton tactics and cuffing transitions drawn from Taiho jutsu and pressure tested in seminar settings.
Who might choose which
- A student seeking philosophic practice and cooperative exploration may prefer orthodox Aikido.
- A police officer, security professional or civilian focused on arrest and control will likely find Icho-ryu’s tested methods more directly relevant.
- Many practitioners train in both strands to keep Aiki principles while building tested options for resisting attackers.
Icho-ryu grew from a specific need encountered by a long time Aikido teacher and police detective. The two systems share common roots in Aiki but differ in methods and testing. Knowing those differences helps a student make a clear choice about training goals and practical outcomes.
Step Onto the Mats
Ready to begin training? Browse verified, unpaywalled schedules and mat fees across UK academies in our Icho-Ryu Directory Finder.
Related Fighting Disciplines: Judo • Kendo • Iaido • Iaijutsu
Browse Training Goals: Self-Defense • Conditioning • Mobility and Longevity • Fight Camp
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should I practice Icho-Ryu each week for steady progress?
Three sessions per week provides an ideal balance of technical repetition and physical recovery.
Where can I find accredited academies in my area?
Use CombatClub's verified directory finder to locate accredited clubs with unpaywalled schedules and verified coaching credentials.
Find Local Icho-Ryu Clubs
Ready to train? Search verified academies offering Icho-Ryu training with transparent timetables and drop-in pricing.